The Return Of The King
There will be SPOILERS, so be forewarned. And, once again, I'm so tired that I'm wavering between complete and total incoherence and dementia and such pure lethargy that I find myself unable to lift my head. So, if this is strange, I'm sure there's about 500 other reviews of this movie going up online as we speak.
What can I say about this movie that hasn't already been said? It's a masterpiece. A flat-out masterpiece that, all at once, makes Fellowship and The Two Towers look even better and even worse.
Before I go on, let me stress that I never read the books. Well, I tried reading Fellowship in high school, but couldn't get past the interminable Bilbo Baggins birthday party. I am anything but a Tolkienophile, and I knew extremely little about the events of this chapter going in. (And most of what I knew was incorrect. For some reason, I've always had it in my head that Frodo dies.)
And, to be honest, I don't really understand those people. I was in Eides Entertainment - a, no, the comic book store - this afternoon, in part of my never-ending and increasingly unsucessful search for my sister's Christmas present - and the clerks are going on and on about insignifigant and petty "mistakes" that "totally ruined the movie". Honestly - if you didn't like this movie, you are impossible to please.
(And, don't get me wrong, I'll be the same way when and if they finally make a series of Dark Tower movies. Hmmm, Viggo Mortensen wouldn't make a bad Roland Deschain, would he?)
Anyway - the movie itself. I've been to a few films where people clapped after the movie was over. If I like the movie, I tend to do this myself, even though I always wind up feeling silly because no one in any way associated with the film was actually, you know, in attendance.
Only once before ("Star Wars: Episode I") can I remember being in a theater where people clapped as soon as the lights dimmed and as soon as the movie started.
And never before can I remember so many people stopping and applauding the screen before. Every moment of triumph was met with a feverous round of applause - and I was right there with them. It's just that kind of movie - the heroes overcoming incredible odds and pulling the impossible, you just can't help but cheer something like that.
And I'm also not ashamed to admit that I cried during quite a few "Sam scenes". (As far as I'm concerned, if you don't cry during movies, you don't have a soul. Period. I can't remember the last time I cried in real life, although I think I shed a tear when Johnny Cash died when my tribute playing of "The Man Comes Around" got to "We'll Meet Again".) Sean Astin and Elijah Wood deserve acting nods at Oscar time every bit as much as this movie deserves to take home Best Picture. (Andy Serkis, of course, deserves a nod once again - and still won't get it, although this time he would justly lose to Astin.) Billy Boyd's Pippen and John Rhys-Davies' Gimli manage to steal pretty much every scene they're in once again.
The battle scenes are amazing. Peter Jackson said something to the effect that this movie would make the Helm's Deep scene look like a pillowfight - and that's no exaggeration. Incredible, and with a bare minimum of that herky-jerky camcorder stuff that most movies like to do in scenes like that which completely hides most of the action.
Perhaps the only flaw with the movie (aside from Not Enough Gimli, but there can't possibly ever be quite enough Gimli) was the overlong ending sequence, but, one, I know Jackson trimmed it way down from what was in the book and, two, it was well after three in the morning when it began and we were all exhausted from the incredibly tense Mount Doom sequence and the long final battle. I'd really have to see it again - and will - in order to make a final judgement.
All in all, I think the classic Star Wars trilogy may finally have been surpassed. (I don't know, though. If the fellowship had an elf, a dwarf and a Wookiee, I'd be willing to say so right now, but I certainly don't want to make such a grand statement without much more time to let the film sink in and at least one or two more viewings. Either way, though, it totally blows that Matrix crap right out of the water.)
********** out of *****. Extremely highly recommended.
(That still only counts as one!)
12.17.2003
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment