Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Review
I have no idea what's taking me so long to type this one up. I saw it last week, and I enjoyed it, so I don't know why I've been sitting on the review. Oh well...
Spoiler mode, you know the drill:
It's really not fair to compare this movie to the "original" with Gene Wilder, but that's what everyone's going to do, myself included. This, of course, isn't a remake of that film, but another adaptation of the Roald Dahl classic, and one that purports to be much closer to the source material at that. Still, even someone who read the novel as many times as I did as a child tends to hold a special place in their heart for the old movie and these two versions are just going to have to be laid side by side.
If that's how we're going to do it, we'll have to start with Wonka himself. Both films had a masterful casting choice - Gene Wilder and Johnny Depp are among the best actors of their respective generations and among the only people who could pull such a bizarre and multi-faceted character off. I've kinda got to give the edge to Wilder here, however. Depp, at points, comes off as silly and goofy, and lacks the outright sincerity that Wilder gave to the role which allowed it to work on the two levels it has. (The straight-forward way you saw it as a child, and the "oh my god, this guy's a fucking sociopath" way you saw it as an adult.)
On the flip side, the rest of the cast is much, much, much better here. Not only is Freddie Highmore quite possibly the best child actor working today - perhaps even eclipsing creepy robot Dakota Fanning - the rest of the kids are, finally, fleshed out characters. In the old film, Veruca is really the only child who comes across as truly wretched. The other three are just kinda...there, and not really deserving of their fate. (I always thought a lifetime as a blueberry was too steep a price to pay for the horrid crime of chewing gum.) Thankfully, this time the rest of the kids get to come across as horrible little monsters, and their parents are even developed to the point that you can see where these horrible little monsters came from. A point for the remake.
Now, the new film professes to be much closer to the books - and for the most part it is - but it does choose to throw in a completely unnecessary and lame subplot about Willy Wonka's childhood with his super-strict dentist father played by Christopher Lee. It's hard to fault a movie for working Christopher Lee in, but this whole sequence was a waste of time and a distraction and only serve to de-mystify the Wonka character and I have no fucking clue why it was there. (I can't decide, however, if it was as big of a crime as the equally "fake" Fizzy Lifting Drink sequence from the first movie which was also overlong and in this case also quite boring and managed to completely deviate from Charlie's character. So, it's a wash.)
Okay, the remake is a Tim Burton movie, so I don't think I have to tell you it wins in the visual competition (and is, in fact, the best looking movie of the year with the possible exception of Sin City thusfar), do I? Didn't think so.
The new one also excises almost all music from the original - another plus in my opinion - and replaces the classic "Oompa Loompa Doompity Do" song with the real ones from the book that, you know, Dahl wrote. I was wary of this at first, but the songs are so fucking awesome - and "performed" with such pizazz by Deep Roy, who plays all the Oompa Loompas, that I have no idea why they weren't used in the first place.
As blasphemous as it may seem to say, it sure seems like the new one's better. I'm not entirely sure about that - I kinda feel like Gene Wilder's performance is worthy of about 50 bonus points - but whatever... I'll go ****. It should be higher, but it's really gotta be punished for that dentist thing. Seriously.
7.29.2005
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment