Donnie Darko: The Director's Cut Review
I'm experimenting with a bit of structure this time. I feel compelled to write these movie reviews, but I hate actually trying to do it. I figure, this'll make it a bit easier. I may go back and re-do some recent ones in this format. Light on the spoilers, but I've blacked out anything that might count.
STARRING: Jake Gyllenhaal, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Holmes Osborne, Daveigh Chase, James Duvall, Jena Malone, Beth Grant, Drew Barrymore, Noah Wyle, Patrick Swayze and famous actor Stuart Stone
DIRECTOR: Richard Kelly's debut and, to date, only film
PLOT: This is still kind of a tough question, although the new director's cut made some efforts to clarify the famously confounding plotline. (More on that later).
Here's the storyline in a nutshell: In a small town right before the 1988 Presidential election, Donnie Darko (Jake Gyllenhaal) has been diagnosed as a schizophrenic. One night, he sneaks out after dark and meets a seven foot tall demonic-looking bunny rabbit named Frank (James Duvall) who tells him that the world is going to end in 28 days. While he's out, a jet engine crashes through the roof of his house - landing on his bed. Then things start to get a bit weird.
WHAT WORKED: Just about everything, really. Great performances right across the board. And, as good as the weird stuff is, where the film really shines is in the typical, believable stuff. Kelly was clearly influenced by the Quentin Tarantino/Kevin Smith movement in the mid-90s, and it shows in scenes featuring, for example, long-winded discussions about the sexual reproductive habits of the Smurfs. Patrick Swayze's entire subplot as hack motivational speaker Jim Cunningham is probably the best part of the movie, and when was the last time you ever said that Patrick Swayze had anything to do with the best part of anything? When was the last time you ever said that Patrick Swayze had anything to do with anything? And it's got Maggie Gyllenhaal in it, which should be enough of a selling point for everyone right there. (Notable exception: Mona Lisa Smile.)
WHAT DIDN'T WORK: Let's face it, while the director's cut added more explanation to the bizarre plot goings-on, mostly through peeks into a book Donnie picks up midway through the film, there's still quite a few plot points that they don't feel it entirely necessary to explain to the movie-going public. (What happens to the plane at the end, for example.)
BEST PERFORMANCE: As tempted as I am to give this to famous actor Stuart Stone's genre-defining performance as the Chinese-insulting, Hulkster-impersonating, Smurf-fucking turn as Ronald, and as tempted as I am to give this to Maggie Gyllenhall entirely because she's Maggie Gyllenhaal, I have to give this one to character actress Beth Grant's show-stealing performance as the high-strung teacher, Kitty Farmer. Every scene she's in, she plays such an unlikable passive-agressive bitch that you can't help but absolutely despise her. Plus, she's the only one who bridges the parent/teacher gap.
FUZZY SEZ: The Director's Cut is an improvement. The music's been changed, but it's been changed to what was originally intended to be included now that the rights have been cleared. (This is usually a postive improvement, but I really miss the creepy counterpoint music that used to accompany Sparkle Motion's big performance.) Quite a few new bizarre compilation shots have been added to bridge scenes, and several deleted scenes have been re-inserted. (Which not only helps explain the weird stuff, it helps flesh out the more typical plotlines that didn't make sense beforehand. Finally, Drew Barrymore gets fired for a reason!)
STAR RATING: ****1/2
8.25.2004
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment