Pirates of the Carribean: Dead Man's Chest Review
Three years ago, Pirates of the Carribean: The Curse of the Black Pearl opened in theaters with no fanfare whatsoever. The second in a line of movies based on Disneyland rides and attractions (between the completely forgettable Country Bears and The Haunted Mansion), most people thought the movie would be awful or didn't give it a second thought at all. But the now iconic performace of Johnny Depp as Jack Sparrow, the exciting action sequences and the unrelenting hotness of Kiera Knightley shocked the world and pushed it to become the highest grossing movie of the year (that wasn't Lord of the Rings or made by Pixar) and netted Depp a shocking Oscar nomination.
Now in 2006, the sequel finds itself in the exact opposite situation. While the original benefitted greatly from the nonexistant expecations for quality, this movie finds itself in the unenviable situation of living up to the public's demands. And it doesn't quite make it.
It's hard to put my finger on what's wrong with the movie. Johnny Depp still is awesome as Jack Sparrow - though he gets less of a chance to be quietly charming alongside his co-stars and more of a chance to camp it up with annoying pratfalls. The action sequences are still great - a showstealing threeway sword fight inside of a giant rolling waterwheel was a particular highlight. And Kiera Knightley is still hot (though she's dressed as a male pirate to stowaway on various ships throughout most of the movie because, as Stephen Colbert pointed out, no one's allowed to be prettier than Orlando Bloom.)
After the movie, Jeff pointed out that it seemed like a commercial for the next sequel (Pirates of the Carribean: At World's End, due Memorial Day next year) and that may sum it up better than I can. It seemed like they were holding back - going at half-speed. Most of the plot threads went unresolved, Davy Jones (an awesome Bill Nighy) never even fights anyone and the unanimous vote for the film's best moment was a last second cameo entirely to set up the next one. We've even got to wait until next year to see Keith Richards.
***1/2. You won't regret seeing it (and, if the box office totals are to be believed, you probably already have), but it's not on par with the first one.
Oh, and much love has to go to Mackenzie Crook who reprises his role here as Ragetti (the pirate with the wooden eye.) In this movie, he practically steals scenes from Johnny Depp and, in a couple of scenes, honestly seems to be playing Gareth Keenan again. Well, Gareth Keenan if he was an uneducated former-zombie pirate, at least. Your MVP of the film!
7.17.2006
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment