11.12.2003

Contest
Who intentionally misinterpreted Tom Tomorrow's latest cartoon the most? First, the cartoon in question:


Your first contestant is Indepundit's Lt. Smash, who decided the entire cartoon must be about him:
I am what you would call a "warblogger." Last year, I wrote several articles calling on the President and Congress to take whatever action necessary to remove Saddam Hussein from power, as I believed (and still do) that he represented a threat to global peace and security.

I am also a reservist. In December, I was recalled to active duty and deployed to the Middle East. I spent eight months in Kuwait and Iraq. I carried a loaded weapon, and had missiles fired at me. In short, I put my money where my mouth was.

I also continued to maintain my weblog, as much as possible from a war zone. And I wasn't the only one, either. In short, the premise of your comic is patently false, and I am living proof.

So, where's the retraction? Do I need to remind you that today is Veterans' Day?

You know, completely missing the first nine words of the comic "While others risked their lives in Iraq and Afghanistan" meaning, in what I'm sure comes as a shock to Mr. Smash, that this comic was seemingly the first thing in the history of the universe that was not about him.

But my vote is for my personal favorite Internet Republican, the ever-inane Pool-Boy, who's always completely outraged about the latest leftist conspiracy to destroy America, Jesus and Ronald Reagan, and he's got several facts he made up to back him up. As always, hilarious spelling and grammar errors are his and un-edited:
SIGH- when did the art of political cartoons change from Biting political satire to overtly biased, pro-liberal, Republicans suck suck suck pictures?

This guy and Tom Toles, I swear. Personally, I can take jokes aimed at Republicans in stride, but things like this are so hateful. And you NEVER see people like this poking at the mistakes in their own party.

Just not funny. Frankly I am getting sick of seeing it. No longer is it two parties comprised of Americans who disagree on things- it is two parties who feel the OTHER is un-American, and wrong in utterly everything they do. Crap like this is part of the reason for that...

So why isn't this "Tom Tomorrow" enlisting? Maybe he has carpel tunnel in his drawing hand? I think it is a tad hypocritical for a political commentator (cartoons) to be bashing another political commentator like this...

"I'm waging war on Ultra-right wing nazis in my cartoon! This Bush speech is perfect! I can draw Bush in a flight suit standing next to General Clark! Screw truth and context, we have a president's caracter to assasinate!"

It's caracter assasination! Later, he shows us his strong grasp on the history of political cartooning in America which I don't have to tell you is exactly the opposite of the truth.
Maybe when I look at "historical" political cartoons, I see a great deal more cleverness and neutrality in the digs. The vast majority of cartoons I see today are much less insiteful, and far more insulting. Maybe it is the eye of history, but maybe it is representative of the political climate of today, which, due largely to the overabundance of media, really has very little basis in fact. It just gets a little tiresome having to listen to empty arguments over and over...


First off, I'm sure he just doesn't understand how to use quotation marks, but assuming he means "historical" ironically, that's just another thing about this guy that pisses me off - lack of respect for the importance and artistic legitimacy of our nation's cartoonists. (He's not alone in that one - I can't even get people here at the Art Institute to look at cartoons as being even remotely on-par with nearly anything else. Remember - Jackson Pollock throwing paint at a canvas makes him an artist - Berkely Breathed just draws silly pictures.)

Sorry, lost my point there for a second... What was I talking about? The dumb-ass!

Anyway, the most striking point in that sentence is his stated desire to see political cartoonists to return to his imagined-yesteryear of "insiteful"-ness and "neutrality". Which is interesting, because I don't know how a political cartoon could exist that doesn't take a side. (I'm thinking of Tom Tomorrow's cartoons featuring Blinky, The Very Nice Dog here.)

And here's the kicker - Pool-Boy's not even the densest Internet Republican I deal with. Maybe some day I'll introduce you to Krydor or even the unwillingly hilarious ArmyOfOne...

No comments: