9.27.2005

The New TV Season...Reviewed!
At least as far as the new series I gave enough of a damn about to check out, and a handful of interesting season premieres.

Rome:
Leave it to HBO. I've never had much of an interest in period pieces - the Roman Empire in particular has failed to hold my attention throughout countless classic movies, but I can't get enough of this show. Much like how they reinvented the Western with Deadwood, they've got an entirely new and unique way of presenting the time period - unapologetically realistic, complete with the graphic violence, foul language and near constant nudity you expect from HBO.

The War At Home:
I wasn't joking or exaggerating in my previous post - this is the worst show I've ever seen. Worse than that show where Snow White and Prince Charming moved into a house in the modern day suburbs. Worse than that show where the dad built a horrifying little girl robot. Even worse than that show no one remembers where the dad married the alien woman and they had all these weird puppet babies*. Just horrifyingly, mind-numbingly awful, complete with desperate "please pay attention to me" attempts at OMG I Can't Believe He Said That political incorrectness. He's upset his daughter's dating a black guy! He worries his son might be teh gay!

In fact, here's how bad the show is - they actually have used virtually identical jokes to the ones found on Room And Bored, the intentionally awful sitcom Lisa Kudrow's character on The Comeback is shooting. Seriously, why this and the improving-but-still-pretty-mediocre American Dad can't disappear and have new episodes of Futurama and the last season of King of the Hill (both in timeslots that won't be pre-empted every week for football) show up in their place is beyond me.

Arrested Development - Season 3 Premiere:
Why aren't you watching this, you stupid motherfuckers? This show is now at the point where, with no exaggeration, I will call this the best half hour comedy on television ever. There has never been, and will never be, another combination of performance, story and writing on television before - network television - to boot, and you assholes are too busy making every tired family comedy CBS shits onto the schedule a huge hit. (He's a schlumpy dad with a really hot wife who just can't handle those kids! Tune in Monday nights for Every Fucking Sitcom On TV!)

Kitchen Confidential:
A good cast, tons of potential and, I'm told by some folks who'd know, fantastic source material. The first episode wasn't that funny, but I'll keep tuning in.

My Name Is Earl:
The exact opposite of my The War At Home mini-review. My Name Is Earl is the most fully realized and hilarious pilot (which, let's face it, are usually among the worst episodes in any show's run) I can remember for any show since the first King of the Hill. (The first Arrested Development was incredibly strong too but, like the rest of the series, improved by leaps and bounds once you "knew" the characters and only truly became great for me on the repeat viewing.)

Earl, quite simply, is the best new comedy on television - hundreds of times funnier than the constant stream of commercials made it seem, with Jason Lee and a nearly unrecognizable Ethan Suplee bringing their View Askew experience to the small screen in a big way. (The American public seems to agree - the first episode was such a rating sucess that it's now the #1 Comedy on Television, overtaking the fantastically mediocre Two and a Half Men.)

The Office - Season 2 Premiere:
I really love the fact that this has become it's own show - when it started, I didn't think there was a chance in hell they could do the BBC Office half as well as Ricky Gervias and company and, as the mediocre pilot proved, they really couldn't. But from then on out, as they moved the main character towards his own direction as

And they're doing the romance right! I was even more worried about their take on the Tim/Dawn relationship being too obvious and sitcom-y than the show being funny (you never have to worry about Steve Carrell not being funny), but they're keeping in unacknowledged and in the background and confined to looks and pauses and it's fucking excellent. (And Dawn, er, Pam's fiancee in this one is even more of a knob that Lee in the original, which only improves things.)

All this show needs is a Finchy and they'll be all set.

Lost - Season 2 Premiere:
So, if you guessed that we'd find an old aquaintance of Jack's juicing up while listening to old Mama Cass songs in the hatch, you really need to help me pick some lottery numbers. (No, not those numbers, thank you.)

Oh, and the way they tortured us by not even giving us one scene with the raft (unless you count that creepy hallucination (?) with Walt and Shannon) is the sort of stuff that everyone else hates and I can't get enough of. Seriously, JJ Abrams has my full permission to drive us crazy for as long as he wants. The speculation is usually more fun than the answers anyway.

Invasion:
Limitless potential, but that's about it at this point. The show, concerning a possible alien invasion during a hurricane, started off with a fairly predictable episode - but with Shaun Cassidy, the man who brought us the criminally underrated Amerian Gothic, behind it, it could move in virtually any direction at this point, and I'll be sticking around for a while.

Joey - Season 2 Premiere:
Why I still watch this show is beyond me. (Actually, the simple answer is habit.) Whatever the reason, it doesn't change the fact that it's unfunny, lazy and filled with one-dimensional characters that are completely impossible to give a damn about. And it's got Jennifer Coolidge on it, causing me to spend the entire half-hour (or, in this case, a completely unnecessary hour-long episode) fantasizing about throwing a rock through her gigantic unfunny head. When you've got a show this lousy, you've really got to dig deep to find someone to be the worst part - Jennifer Coolidge has made quite a career out of being the worst part of a mediocre project from the American Pie movies to that awful looking Robots film. (to be fair, occasionally she turns up in a Christopher Guest movie to be the worst part of something great as well.)

As for the show itself, Kevin Smith was kinda funny in his cameo but I hope that the writers don't think Black Chandler is all they need to fix this sinking ship. They've even finally lost me as a viewer because it's on against...

Everybody Hates Chris:
Chris is my real first name, so my only real hope going into this show was that it would become sucessful enough to warrant printing up a few t-shirts with the show's title on it. Aside from that, I mean, it's on UPN, for fuck's sake. Enough said.

Or not, because for the first time in the network's history, UPN has an excellent show**. In fact, there are now five great sitcoms on television - six when Scrubs finally returns (the others are all in this list), which I thought would never happen again. This show, in particular, is not only funny but has that "real" quality than early episodes of Roseanne and the first non-shitty season of Grace Under Fire brought to the screen. And it's easily supplated the latent-Friends fandom on my Thursday nights.

Curb Your Enthusiasm - Season 5 Premiere:
Truth be told, it was kind of a weak episode - but that's par for the course with this show's season premieres. They're more about setting up the season's overriding story arc (this year Larry attempting to find out if he was adopted based on something he thinks his father may have said after suffering a stroke. "He could've said I was a doctor.")

Extras:
If what Pat said is true and the series only improves from here**, we've got the new best show on television on our hands. That's all I need to say.



*:
The Charmings, Small Wonder and Aliens In The Family

**:
The nerd in me wants to point out that WWE Smackdown was excellent in late 2002 when they just sent Kurt Angle, Chris Benoit, Rey Mysterio Jr., Edge and Los Guerreros out there to tear shit up every week, but that's not really what I'm talking about here.

***: This may not, in fact, be accurate because we actually saw the third episode in the series last week - the one with Kate Winslet - and won't be seeing the "proper" series premiere until next week.

No comments: