2.09.2007

This Film Is Not Yet Rated Review
Another documentary review, and a pretty short one at that. How much could I say on this movie when the filmmakers couldn't even pad the topic out to an hour and a half? The movie is about the MPAA and the film rating system - how an NC-17 rating movie can essentially bankrupt a picture and how abritrary the ratings system is (generally illustrated with side-by-side shots of R and NC-17 films which are generally indistinguishable). There's a lot of talk about how movies with gay themes get hit a lot harder (including an inexplicable NC-17 rating for the nudity-free But I'm A Cheerleader). And there's a lot of interviews with frustrated movie directors from Kevin Smith and Matt Stone to Jon Waters and Kimberly Pierce. And, all in all, that takes about twenty minutes.

So how do we fill time? With some hired private investigators, sent to determine the identities of the secret ratings panel. Which goes nowhere. Slowly. Very, very, very slowly. Well over half the movie is poking through trashcans and trailing random people to lunch to determine that the ratings board is made up of...people you've never heard of.

**, it could've ran in a half hour on HBO without the superfluous nonsense and been much better off for it.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I have to disagree with you on this one. I thought the revelation of who the people on the board are was rather interesting. The thing is, the MPAA claim the board is made up of parents of children ages 5 to 17, or something like that. And that description, as far as I can remember, only fits one or two members. Some never even had kids. So why are they the ones telling "other parents" what's ok for their kids to see? Also, many of them are registered Republicans. Why the obvious bias? And why only filthy rich, mostly white people? I also found the military aspects quite fascinating, as I had no idea about that stuff before. If it's true, then that part explains a lot of my ponderings about why American war movies are always the way they are. Sure, a little too much detective footage perhaps, but all in all an entertaining and very interesting documentary, I thought. Comparing the MPAA's ratings to those in other countries adds to the experience, as well.